Showing posts with label poker online. Show all posts
Showing posts with label poker online. Show all posts

Saturday, December 15, 2007

Do we have to worry about bots?

At the online poker tables, you're pitted against other people in that age-old poker exercise of taking their money.

Sometimes, however, you have those nights when no bluff works, your second pair or ace-high bluff is picked off by another player's accurate play or you're run down on the river by a better hand.

While many players will just shut down the tables and write the night off, some ask the question, "Hey, am I playing against a bot?"

Rumors about the existence of pokerbots - computer-created programs that can play for hours on end without a break, that make the optimal move at all times and that allegedly can turn a profit - have permeated forums since the dawn of online poker.

Any Internet search engine will yield thousands of hits for products claiming to be this kind of program. The reality, however, is that the technology isn't quite up to speed when it comes to bots for full ring games and tournaments.

Computer whizzes have long been devising programs capable of challenging the best human gamers in the world. For games with few moves and deviations, such as checkers, Scrabble and Connect Four, these programs have been able to defeat even the best that the human race has to offer. For more complex games, it took a bit more development work.

Chess computers circa 1990 weren't able to even approach the grandmasters of the game. That all changed in 1997 when Deep Blue, a computer created by IBM expressly to play chess, defeated world chess champion Garry Kasparov in a hard-fought series of matches (although the computer's victory remains controversial to this day).

A poker program that can beat human players is one of the more recent targets of developers, and they've been making great strides toward that goal. The University of Alberta's Computer Poker Research Group has been at the forefront of this movement.

The U of A team first created Poki and PsOpti, aka SparBot (the latter of which has been used in both Daniel Negreanu's video game "Stacked" and the Poker Academy Pro computer program). Then, earlier this year, they unveiled Polaris. Of these programs, Polaris has shown the most promise (or threat, depending on how you look at it).

In July, Polaris squared off against champion poker players Phil Laak and Ali Eslami, with the criterion for victory being cash won or lost by each of the players. In a five-session series, the computer played both players individually heads-up, which yielded startling results.

Polaris was able to reach a statistical draw with the two poker pros in the first match before winning the second round. Laak and Eslami, though, were able to strike a blow for carbon-based life forms by winning the next three sessions, albeit by very small margins.

While they demonstrated that humans could still beat computers, the final score was close enough to indicate that programming had come a long way. That said, pokerbots playing online isn't something players should be excessively concerned about.

While there are several programs advertised online that state they can play just as well as the University of Alberta's, the reality is they cannot; it's merely marketing bafflegab. Even the creators of Polaris state that their program can achieve winning results heads-up only; it's at a loss confronted with multi-way hand or full table parameters.

Furthermore, they maintain that Polaris only works in a cash game situation and not in tournaments. (Admittedly, cash games are often more profitable than tournaments). Finally, the computers we are talking about here are full-fledged systems dedicated solely to the game at hand, requiring computing capacity in the terabytes to accurately deduce their strategy.

Online poker sites are also aware of the potential for pokerbot situations. The poker sites monitor length of time at the cash game tables and, upon coming across players who haven't moved from tables in an inhuman amount of time, disconnect them.

Pokerbots, though, are probably more of a scapegoat than a reality in online play. Cries of "pokerbot" may well be rooted in human beings' capacity for denial. Even beat after beat, it's hard to face the fact that you're just not playing at an optimal level.

Instead, players ignore how badly they're running and foist the blame on a program. The simplest explanation is discounted in favor of a more elaborate one that lets them off the hook. This isn't to say that, given inevitable advances in computing capability and artificial intelligence, functioning pokerbots are out of the question.

With an AI sophisticated enough to take into account other players' styles and adjust its own game, they could be viable. That technology, however, is likely still a few years away, making it futile for online players to worry about it at this point.

So the next time you feel you are up against a bot, take a long, hard look at your own play. Those miraculous 5% chances do come home on the river sometimes. There are players who can pick off your bluffs better than any machine could, and there are players capable of waging optimal poker war for long sessions. Pokerbots shouldn't be your primary concern.

PartyPoker $300,000 Guaranteed

PartyPoker again cleared its guarantee, with 1,534 players making for a $306,800 prize pool. First place would receive $61,360 and 200 places were paid.

Leaving in tenth as this final table began was Fold4V4lue, who went all in, in the small blind. ababababba called. Fold4V4lue flipped (A-Diamonds)(4-Clubs) to ababababba's (A-Spades)(10-Spades). The board was (9-Hearts)(10-Clubs)(J-Hearts)(3-Spades)(10-Hearts). Fold4V4lue did not fold this one for value, and left in tenth for $2,914.60.

Next, Montaigne1 raised 2x and M0NGY re-raised all in. huilaiqiao called all in, in the short stack. Montaigne1 folded and M0NGY took almost his whole stack back. M0NGY had (A-Clubs)(Q-Hearts) to huilaiqiao's (J-Hearts)(4-Hearts). The board was (6-Clubs)(Q-Clubs)(J-Spades)(6-Spades)(4-Clubs) and huilaiqiao left in ninth for $4,141.80.

TRESprinceTIhof raised to 165,000 and Ota_SolGryn re-raised all in. TRESprinceTIhof called with (K-Diamonds)(K-Hearts) to Ota-SolGryn's (7-Clubs)(7-Diamonds). The board was (K-Clubs)(A-Hearts)(5-Hearts)(2-Diamonds)(J-Clubs) and Ota_SolGryn was out in eighth for $5,369.

Next, Montaigne1 shoved under the gun and savveboy called, also all in. Montaigne1 had (A-Hearts)(9-Clubs) to savveboy's (3-Diamonds)(3-Spades) and the board was (Q-Spades)(4-Spades)(8-Diamonds)(6-Hearts)(10-Diamonds). Montaigne1 left in seventh for $8,130.20.

After that, M0NGY raised to 180,000 and allminequick re-raises all in. M0NGY called with (8-Spades)(8-Clubs) to allminequick's (J-Diamonds)(J-Clubs). The beat was placed with a board of (7-Hearts)(8-Diamonds)(6-Clubs)(A-Clubs)(4-Diamonds) and allminequick left in sixth for $10,584.60.

Next, ababababba raised to 166,000 and savveboy re-raised all in. ababababba called with (J-Diamonds)(9-Diamonds) to savveboy's (A-Diamonds)(J-Clubs). Another beat with a board of (6-Diamonds)(9-Spades)(10-Spades)(5-Hearts)(4-Clubs), and savveboy was out in fifth for $14,112.80.

Again, ababababba made a preflop raise, this time to 180,000. M0NGY re-raised all in and ababababba called, showing (A-Diamonds)(J-Hearts) to M0NGY's (K-Clubs)(J-Clubs). The board was (6-Clubs)(Q-Spades)(8-Spades)(J-Spades)(4-Diamonds) and M0NGY was sent home in fourth for $16,720.60.

In third was the player with the amusing name of hellmuthaments. He open-shoved on the button and TRESprinceTIhof called with (Q-Clubs)(J-Diamonds). hellmuthaments had (K-Diamonds)(5-Hearts). The board was (3-Diamonds)(4-Spades)(Q-Spades)(3-Hearts)(Q-Diamonds) and hellmuthaments was out in third for $21,169.20.

Entering heads up, ababababba held just over a 2:1 lead. The players would fight it out over 20 minutes. In the last hand, TRESprinceTIhof raised to 275,000 preflop and ababababba called. The flop was (4-Clubs)(A-Hearts)(K-Diamonds). ababababba checked and TRESprinceTIhof bet 325,000. ababababba called. The turn was (10-Spades). ababababba bet 750,000. TRESprinceTIhof raised ababababba all in, and ababababba called with (K-Clubs)(10-Diamonds) to TRESprinceTIhof's (A-Clubs)(4-Diamonds). The river was (3-Diamonds) and two pair beat two pair. ababababba collected $33,748 for second, and TRESprinceTIhof got $61,360, winning the Party Poker $300,000 Guaranteed.

Final Standings:

1st: TRESprinceTIhof — $61,360
2nd: ababababba — $33,748
3rd: hellmuthaments — $21,169.20
4th: M0NGY — $16,720.60
5th: savveboy — $14,112.80
6th: allminequick — $10,584.60
7th: Montaigne1 — $8,130.20
8th: Ota_SolGryn — $5,369
9th: huilaiqiao — $4,141.80
10th: Fold4V4lue — $2,914.60